It is a serious matter when the people entrusted to enforce the law mishandle an investigation. A flawed investigation can lead to a person being charged on weak or improperly gathered evidence. The Constitution sets limits on how police and prosecutors may investigate and prosecute a case, and a defense attorney can review whether those limits were respected in yours.
If you believe that your case has been mishandled by the police and want more information about what that means, contact a criminal defense attorney at Touma Law Group.
How Criminal Investigations Are Mishandled
Not all police officers are corrupt or incompetent, and not every mistake changes the outcome of a case. Here are some of the issues that the Constitution and the courts address most directly.
Coercion and Force
Coercion can occur during an interrogation, when intimidation, psychological pressure, or physical force is used to get a suspect to confess. The Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment does not allow a conviction that rests on confessions extorted by officers through brutality and violence (Brown v. Mississippi, 297 U.S. 278 (1936)). In addition, the prosecution may not use statements that come from custodial interrogation unless it shows that procedural safeguards were used to protect the privilege against self-incrimination (Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966)). The South Carolina Constitution also provides that no person may be compelled in a criminal case to be a witness against himself or herself (S.C. Const. art. I, § 12).

Understanding your rights during interrogation is important, and having a criminal defense attorney with you is important.
Making Deals or Offering Leniency in Exchange for Testimony
Police and prosecutors sometimes offer leniency to a witness or suspect in exchange for testimony. The problem arises when the testimony is false or the deal is hidden. A State may not knowingly use false evidence, including false testimony, to obtain a conviction, even when the false testimony goes only to the credibility of a witness (Napue v. Illinois, 360 U.S. 264 (1959)). When the prosecution fails to disclose a promise made to its key witness, due process can require a new trial (Giglio v. United States, 405 U.S. 150 (1972)).
Failing to Investigate Thoroughly
An investigation that overlooks leads, fails to gather critical evidence, or does not interview witnesses can leave gaps in the State’s case. The State has the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt (In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358 (1970)), and your attorney can point out what the investigation did not do. An incomplete investigation matters in every type of case, including sex crime charges.
Planting or Tampering With Critical Evidence
Fabricating or tampering with evidence is serious misconduct, and it can violate the due process rights of the person accused. Federal law makes it a crime for a person acting under color of law to willfully deprive another person of rights protected by the Constitution (18 U.S.C. § 242), and a person whose rights are violated by someone acting under color of state law may have a civil claim under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
Related Content: Understanding Your 4th Amendment Rights
Bias and Prejudice
Police officers, like any other people, can bring personal biases into an investigation. The Fourteenth Amendment provides that no State may deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws (U.S. Const. amend. XIV), and the South Carolina Constitution has the same protection (S.C. Const. art. I, § 3). Bias is not always intentional, and an attorney can look at how your case was investigated and charged.
Ignoring or Hiding Exculpatory Evidence
Exculpatory evidence is information that tends to show a person’s innocence or that may reduce guilt. The Supreme Court has held that the suppression by the prosecution of evidence favorable to an accused, upon request, violates due process where the evidence is material either to guilt or to punishment, regardless of the good or bad faith of the prosecution (Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963)). The prosecutor has a duty to learn of any favorable evidence known to others acting on the government’s behalf in the case, including the police (Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419 (1995)). In South Carolina, the defense can also request the evidence the State must disclose under Rule 5 of the South Carolina Rules of Criminal Procedure.
What Determines a Botched Investigation?
Ultimately, it is up to the courts to decide whether an investigation was mishandled. A defense attorney may look for signs such as:
- The suspect alleges coercion or force during questioning
- Physical evidence contradicts witness testimony
- Witnesses change or take back their statements
- Evidence appears to have been tampered with or is missing
- There are inconsistencies in the police report or in the officers’ testimony
- Evidence that is favorable to the defense was not disclosed
Can a Case Be Thrown Out Because of Police Mistakes?
Police mistakes do not automatically end a case. What a court can do depends on the mistake. For example:
- Miranda. The prosecution may not use statements that come from custodial interrogation unless it shows that the required safeguards were used (Miranda v. Arizona). Our article on Miranda rights explains them in more detail.
- Illegal searches and seizures. The exclusionary rule applies in state courts, so evidence obtained through an unconstitutional search and seizure can be challenged (Mapp v. Ohio, 367 U.S. 643 (1961)). See our article on unlawful search and seizure.
- False statements in a warrant affidavit. In a case about a search warrant affidavit, the Supreme Court held that when a defendant makes a substantial preliminary showing that a false statement was included knowingly and intentionally, or with reckless disregard for the truth, and the statement was necessary to the finding of probable cause, the Fourth Amendment requires a hearing on the defendant’s request (Franks v. Delaware, 438 U.S. 154 (1978)). The South Carolina Supreme Court applies that rule to search warrant affidavits. The defendant must prove that the officer knowingly and intentionally, or with reckless disregard for the truth, included false statements, and must establish the falsity by a preponderance of the evidence. If that is shown, the court looks at whether the rest of the affidavit still supports probable cause (State v. Robinson, Opinion No. 27617 (S.C. 2016)).
- Failure to disclose evidence. If a party does not comply with the discovery rule, the court may order discovery or inspection, grant a continuance, or prohibit the party from introducing evidence that was not disclosed (S.C. Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 5).

If a court excludes key evidence, the State may have a harder time proving its case. The solicitor decides whether the case continues, and the result depends on the evidence that remains.
What Happens if a Case Is Dismissed?
Many people assume that if a case is dismissed, they walk away with a clean record. That is not always so. If a magistrate finds a lack of probable cause at a preliminary hearing, the defendant is discharged, but the State may begin another prosecution for the same offense (S.C. Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 2).
The arrest record can also remain after a dismissal unless it is expunged.
If a person was charged and the charge was discharged, dismissed, or ended in a finding of not guilty, the person may be able to have the record expunged, and the application is administered by the solicitor’s office (S.C. Code Ann. § 17-22-910). After an expungement on those grounds, the arrest and booking record, mug shots, and fingerprints must be destroyed, but law enforcement and prosecution agencies must keep the information under seal for three years and 120 days and may keep it longer for ongoing or future investigations and prosecutions and for certain other purposes (S.C. Code Ann. § 17-1-40).
To learn more, read our article on expungement in South Carolina. Specific requirements must be met to qualify.
Final Thoughts
Police mishandling of an investigation can affect both the person accused and the victim of the crime. The rules about interrogations, searches, and evidence exist so that cases are decided on accurate and lawfully gathered evidence.
If you think your rights were not respected in an investigation, it is important to understand the law and to talk with an attorney about the steps you can take.
Call Touma Law Group Today if You Believe Your Case Has Been Mishandled
If you believe that the police mishandled an investigation involving yourself or a loved one, it is important to seek legal counsel immediately. You may also consider filing a complaint about the officers involved with the law enforcement agency. The attorneys at Touma Law Group can review your case and explain your options. Contact us today for a consultation at 864-618-2323.