What You Can Expect From the Criminal Appeals Process in SC

13 min read Aug 9, 2024 Criminal Defense
What You Can Expect From the Criminal Appeals Process in SC

Navigating the criminal appeals process in South Carolina can be a daunting task, especially for those unfamiliar with the legal system. Understanding how to challenge a conviction or sentence is important for anyone who believes errors were made during a trial. From filing the initial notice of appeal to presenting arguments before the appellate court, this article covers each stage so that you are better informed about the steps and the deadlines.

If you or a loved one is considering an appeal in South Carolina, speak with a lawyer as soon as possible, because the first deadline is very short. A Greenville criminal appeals attorney can explain the procedures that apply to your case and review whether an appeal is available.

Contact Touma Law today at (864) 618-2323 for a free consultation to discuss your case and your options in the appeals process. This article is general information. A licensed South Carolina attorney at our firm must review the facts of your case before you rely on it.

File the Notice of Appeal

The first step in the appeals process is the notice of appeal. This document tells the court and the other side that you intend to challenge the conviction or sentence. The deadline is short. After a plea or trial that results in a conviction, or after a proceeding that results in revocation of probation, a notice of appeal must be served on all respondents within 10 days after the sentence is imposed. A timely post-trial motion under Rule 29(a) of the South Carolina Rules of Criminal Procedure stays that time, and the time to appeal then runs from receipt of written notice of the order granting or denying the motion (SCACR Rule 203(b)(2)).

After it is served, the notice of appeal must be filed with the clerk of the lower court and the clerk of the appellate court within 10 days. If the notice of appeal is not timely filed, the appeal is dismissed and can be reinstated only as Rule 260 allows (SCACR Rule 203(d)). The filing fee that applies to civil appeals is not required for criminal appeals.

The notice of appeal must include specific information:

  • The name of the court, the judge and the county from which the appeal is taken.
  • The docket number of the case in the lower court.
  • The date of the order, judgment or sentence being appealed.
  • The name of the party taking the appeal.
  • The names, mailing addresses and telephone numbers of all attorneys of record.

These contents are listed in SCACR Rule 203(e)(1). If the appeal is from a guilty plea, an Alford plea or a plea of no contest, the notice must be accompanied by a written explanation showing that there is an issue that can be reviewed on appeal, and the notice may be dismissed if the explanation is not sufficient (SCACR Rule 203(d)(1)(B)(iv)).

Most criminal appeals from the circuit court are filed with the Court of Appeals. An appeal from a final judgment that includes a sentence of death goes directly to the Supreme Court (S.C. Code Ann. § 14-8-200).

an attorney filling out an appeals form

Both sides then submit written briefs to the appellate court. The appellant’s brief identifies the issues the appellant says were decided wrongly and argues why the conviction or sentence should be reversed or modified. The State, as respondent, files a brief that responds to those arguments and defends the trial court’s decision.

In some cases, the appellate court may schedule oral arguments, where both sides present their case and answer questions from the judges. The court may also decide a case without oral argument if it decides that oral argument would not help it resolve the issues (SCACR Rule 215).

Prepare the Record

In a criminal appeal, one of the first tasks is assembling the record on appeal, which includes the trial transcript and the other documents the parties designate. For an appeal from the Court of General Sessions, the appellant must order the transcript from the court reporter within 30 days after the notice of appeal is served (SCACR Rule 207(a)(1)). The court reporter must deliver the transcript no later than 60 days after the request, although extensions are possible (SCACR Rule 207(a)(2) and (a)(3)). Each party also serves a designation that identifies the parts of the transcript, orders, exhibits and other materials to include in the record (SCACR Rule 209).

The record is the basis of the appeal. The record on appeal cannot include matter that was not presented to the lower court (SCACR Rule 210(c)), which is why an appeal is not a new trial and why new evidence is not presented to the appellate court. A missing or incomplete record can make it hard for the court to understand the alleged error. A lawyer can help make sure that the relevant parts of the proceeding are included and that they match what happened at trial.

Appellate Briefs

The appellate brief is the main document in a criminal appeal. It is how you present your arguments to the appellate court. The appellant’s brief must include, under appropriate headings, a statement of the issues on appeal, and ordinarily the court will not consider a point that is not set out in that statement (SCACR Rule 208(b)(1)(B)). In practice, a brief typically includes:

  • Statement of the Facts: A recounting of the events based on the trial record.
  • Legal Arguments: Arguments explaining why the trial court’s decision was incorrect, supported by statutes, case law and other authority.
  • References to the Record: Citations to the specific parts of the transcript and other documents that support each argument.

The deadlines are set by rule. The appellant’s brief is due within 30 days after the appellant receives the transcript, or within 30 days after serving the notice of appeal if no transcript is ordered. If the appellant does not file a brief on time, the clerk signs an order dismissing the appeal (SCACR Rule 208(a)(1) and (a)(4)).

The respondent, usually the State, may then file a brief within 30 days after the appellant’s brief is served. The respondent’s brief responds to the appellant’s arguments and explains why the conviction or sentence should be upheld. The appellant may file a reply brief within 10 days after the respondent’s brief is served (SCACR Rule 208(a)(2) and (a)(3)). After the record on appeal is served, each party serves and files a final brief within 20 days (SCACR Rule 211(a)).

Oral Arguments

Once the briefs are filed, the appellate court may schedule oral argument. Before each term of court, the clerk sends the parties a roster showing the dates fixed for the hearing of the cases in which oral argument will be heard (SCACR Rule 216). Oral argument is a chance for both sides to present their positions in person and answer questions from the judges. Here is what to expect:

  • Preparation: Attorneys review the trial record and the briefs and prepare for questions from the judges.
  • Presentation: Each side explains its position. The court sets the format and the time for argument.
  • Questions from Judges: The judges may interrupt to ask questions about points of law or fact. Those questions can show which issues the judges find most significant.
  • Focus on Key Issues: Oral argument is not a repeat of the briefs. It is a chance to emphasize the key issues and respond to the other side’s points.

Role of the Appellate Judges

The appellate judges do the following during oral argument and throughout the appeals process:

  • Reviewing the Record and Briefs: Before oral argument, the judges review the record and the briefs submitted by both parties.
  • Asking Questions: The judges ask questions to clarify the arguments, test the strengths and weaknesses of each side’s position and explore the legal issues.
  • Deliberating and Making a Decision: After oral argument, the judges consider the written briefs and the oral presentations and decide the case.
  • Issuing a Written Opinion: The court makes its decisions in writing, either in a published opinion or in a memorandum opinion. The court may affirm, reverse or modify the decision below, or send all or any of the issues back for further proceedings (SCACR Rule 220(a)).

a judge seated at their bench

The Appellate Court Makes a Decision

How long a decision takes depends on the complexity of the case, the court’s workload and other factors. The rules do not give the court a deadline for ruling, and no one can tell you in advance how long your appeal will take.

Possible Outcomes

Once the appellate court has reviewed the case, the court may reach one of several outcomes:

  • Affirm: The appellate court upholds the trial court’s decision. The conviction or sentence stays in place unless a higher court takes the case.
  • Reverse: The appellate court overturns the trial court’s decision. What happens next depends on the reason for the reversal. The case may be sent back for a new trial or other proceedings.
  • Remand: The appellate court sends all or some of the issues back to the trial court for further proceedings.
  • Modify: The appellate court changes the trial court’s decision without overturning it entirely, for example by correcting the sentence.

Next Steps if the Appeal Is Successful or Unsuccessful

If the appeal is successful:

  • For Reversal: The next steps depend on the reason for the reversal and on what the State decides to do. The State may be able to retry the case, depending on the nature of the reversal.
  • For Remand: Further proceedings take place in the trial court on the issues the appellate court sent back.
  • For Modification: The trial court carries out the changes the appellate court ordered.

If the appeal is unsuccessful:

  • Rehearing: A petition for rehearing must be received by the appellate court no later than 15 days after the opinion is filed (SCACR Rule 221(a)). The remittitur, which returns the case to the lower court, is not sent until 15 days have passed after the filing of the opinion, and it is held back while a rehearing petition is pending (SCACR Rule 221(b)).
  • Further Appeals: A decision of the Court of Appeals may be reviewed by the South Carolina Supreme Court only by a writ of certiorari, which is not a matter of right. The petition is due within 30 days after the petition for rehearing is finally decided, and the Supreme Court grants it only where there are special and important reasons (SCACR Rule 242). If a federal question is involved, a petition to the U.S. Supreme Court is generally due within 90 days (28 U.S.C. § 1257(a); Supreme Court Rule 13).
  • Finality of Conviction: If no further appeals are pursued or higher courts deny review, the conviction stands and the sentence must be carried out. A person may still have other options, such as a post-conviction relief application, which has its own one year deadline (S.C. Code Ann. § 17-27-45). Our article on post-conviction relief explains how it differs from an appeal.

Understanding the possible outcomes and the next steps after an appeal can help you plan. A South Carolina appellate attorney can review the facts of your case and explain the options that apply.

Grounds for Filing an Appeal

Understanding the grounds for filing an appeal for a criminal case matters in South Carolina. Appeals focus on legal errors made in the trial court. Some claims, such as ineffective assistance of counsel and newly discovered evidence, are usually raised through other procedures, as explained below.

One of the primary grounds for filing an appeal is a legal error during the trial. These errors can include improper jury instructions, incorrect rulings on the admissibility of evidence or a misinterpretation of the law by the trial judge. An error can support an appeal when it affected the fairness of the trial or the validity of the conviction.

Misinterpretation or Misapplication of the Law

If the trial court misinterpreted or misapplied the law in a way that adversely affected the outcome, this can be a ground for appeal. This includes situations where the judge applied the wrong legal standard.

scales of justice and a gavel in front of a dark blue background

Insufficient Evidence to Support the Verdict

An appeal can argue that the evidence presented at trial was not enough to support the guilty verdict. The question is whether, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the prosecution, a rational trier of fact could have found the essential elements of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt (Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307 (1979)).

Ineffective Assistance of Counsel

A defendant has the constitutional right to effective legal representation. The standard comes from Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (1984): the defendant must show that the lawyer’s performance was deficient and that the deficiency prejudiced the defense. In South Carolina, this claim is usually raised in a post-conviction relief application rather than a direct appeal (S.C. Code Ann. § 17-27-20).

Prosecutorial Misconduct

Prosecutorial misconduct can be a ground for appeal. Examples include the suppression of evidence favorable to the accused when the evidence is material to guilt or punishment (Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963)) and the knowing use of false evidence (Napue v. Illinois, 360 U.S. 264 (1959)).

Juror Misconduct

If jurors engage in improper behavior, such as being exposed to outside information or an outside influence, this can be raised as a ground for relief. Juror misconduct can be difficult to prove, because a juror generally may not testify about statements made during deliberations or about the effect of anything on a juror’s mind (Rule 606(b) of the South Carolina Rules of Evidence).

Newly Discovered Evidence

New evidence that was not available at the original trial is not presented to the appellate court, because the record on appeal cannot include matter that was not presented to the lower court. A motion for a new trial based on after-discovered evidence must be made within one year after the evidence was actually discovered or could have been found with reasonable diligence (Rule 29(b) of the South Carolina Rules of Criminal Procedure).

Sentencing Errors

Errors in sentencing, such as a sentence that exceeds the maximum authorized by law, can be challenged. South Carolina’s post-conviction relief statute lists a sentence that exceeds the maximum authorized by law as a ground for relief (S.C. Code Ann. § 17-27-20(A)(3)).

If you believe any of these grounds apply to your case, a South Carolina criminal appeals attorney can review the record and explain which procedure fits and what deadlines apply.

Get Help With an Appeal From Touma Law Group

The steps in a criminal appeal are detailed, from filing the notice of appeal to the briefs and any oral argument, and the deadlines are short. If you want to file an appeal for a criminal case, do not wait.

If you or someone you know is facing a criminal appeal, contact our criminal appeals lawyers in Columbia to schedule a consultation. Our team can review the facts of the case and explain the process. No lawyer can promise how an appeal will turn out.

Adam Touma, founding attorney at Touma Law Group
Adam Touma

Adam Touma is a recognized criminal defense attorney in South Carolina with extensive experience defending the rights of his clients. As a founding partner of Touma Law Group, he specializes in a wide range of criminal cases, from misdemeanors to complex federal litigation, offering tenacious and dedicated legal representation.


Attorney-Approved Content: A collaboration between AI, legal editors, and experienced attorneys, delivering accurate, human-verified content.


Related Articles